Question:
In veterans of the armed forces with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), how effective are trauma-focussed CBT (TFCBT), eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing (EMDR) and narrative exposure therapy, compared to any other non-pharmacological interventions, specifically metaphors of movement, neuro-linguistic programming(NLP), hypnotherapy, integral eye movement therapy and emotional freedom technique, in reducing PTSD symptoms?
Answer:
Evidence from two systematic reviews,
both with significant methodological weaknesses, indicated that
TFCBT and EMDR were similarly effective in treating PTSD, where the
type of trauma experienced by study participants was not specified.
In both reviews, evidence specific to combat veterans was
substantially weaker. The first review included one study in combat
veterans which indicated that the effect of EMDR on clinician-rated
PTSD symptoms was smaller in this population than in the overall
PTSD population and that the effect of TFCBT on clinician-rated
PTSD symptoms was non-significant. There was some indication, from
studies included in the second review, that EMDR was more effective
that ET or biofeedback-assisted relaxation techniques in treating
PTSD symptoms in combat veterans and that the addition of
behavioural family therapy to ET did not improve its effectiveness.
One large (n=360) study, included in this review, indicated that
trauma-focused group psychotherapy (TFGP) and present-centred group
treatment (PCGT) were similarly effective. One additional small,
high quality RCT indicated that EMDR and EFT were similarly
effective in improving PTSD symptoms, depression scores and
satisfaction with life, where the type of trauma experienced by
study participants was not specified and it was not clear whether
any combat veterans were included in the study. Overall, there was
reasonably reliable evidence that TFCBT and EMDR are similarly
effective in treating general PTSD and some evidence, from one RCT,
that EFT may also be similarly effective. However, there was
very little evidence specific to the comparative effectiveness of
different psychological interventions for the treatment of PTSD in
combat veterans; the small amount of evidence available indicated
that EMDR may be the most effective of the psychological
interventions assessed.
Larger, high quality randomised controlled trials are needed to
provide reliable assessments of the relative effectiveness of
different psychological interventions for the treatment PTSD.
Trials conducted in combat veterans are particularly needed, as
this population is currently under represented in the evidence
base.